While Sutton was on a business trip, she discovered her husband Jacob was having an affair with his colleague, Jessie, who was pregnant. Jacob’s harsh reaction—”I don’t regret anything”—and his departure left Sutton devastated. Months later, feeling betrayed, Sutton planned her revenge.

She found Jacob’s treasured keychain and called him, setting a rendezvous for Saturday, the day Jessie was due. “Come get it on Saturday or it’s going in the bin,” Sutton said. Jacob, eager to avoid missing his child’s birth, agreed.

During Jacob’s visit, Sutton pretended to discuss custody and offered him coffee. Unbeknownst to him, a nanny camera recorded their interaction, which Sutton later sent to Jessie. The video suggested Jacob’s lingering affection for Sutton, leading Jessie to ban him from the hospital.

Jacob’s life unraveled, with his job and relationships deteriorating. Sutton felt a pang of regret when her son Danny asked about his father, but reassured him, “I love you, Danny, and that’s all that matters.”